Scam trends · Member protection
24.4% of the people we asked have received a suspicious account renewal email
How fake renewal email scams work, and what credit unions and community banks can do about them.
Alec Glassman, Founder, SilverShield · Published November 18, 2026
Key takeaways
- Fake renewal emails work because people are used to acting on renewal notices. A missed one can mean a lost service or an unexpected charge.
- The email is only the hook. The loss comes from the "refund" call that follows, and a real refund never requires installing software or sending money back.
- Credit unions and community banks can help protect their members with one warning message, one teller question and a quick plan for remote access cases.
Have you ever received an email saying an account is about to renew, and something about it seemed off? When we asked the people we protect, 24.4% said yes.
That is roughly one in four. People are used to paying attention to renewal notices, because a missed renewal can mean a lost service or an unexpected charge. Scammers build on that habit. When a fake renewal works, the money the scammer asks for comes out of their bank account or card.
How does a fake account renewal scam work?
The email looks like routine billing. It names a familiar service, a subscription such as a tech support plan, or an account manager, and it says a renewal has been charged or is about to be. It gives the recipient a phone number to call to cancel or dispute the charge.
- The phone number connects to the scammer. A person who calls that number to cancel the renewal reaches a scammer posing as the company's support team. The caller offers a refund and often asks them to install remote access software to process it. A real refund does not need that. With that access, the scammer can steal online banking credentials.
- A fake refund page collects bank details. The caller may send the person to a website that looks real and ask them to enter bank or card information to process the refund. The scammer can use that information to get into the account or run charges on the card.
- The refund turns into a payment. The scammer then claims they refunded too much by mistake. They pressure the person to send back the difference by wire, gift cards, or cryptocurrency.
The FTC describes this same pattern in its guide to tech support scams.
What can credit unions and community banks do this month?
- Name the refund script in your next member message. Tell members plainly that a company that wants to refund you does not need you to install software or send money back. Add a line in your own voice: "We will never ask you to buy gift cards or move money to fix a refund."
- Give frontline staff one question to ask. When a member requests a wire, a large cash withdrawal, or help buying cryptocurrency, staff can ask whether someone is helping them with a refund or a cancellation. A yes gives the teller a reason to slow down and talk it through with the member.
- Treat remote access as an account incident. If a member says they let someone onto their computer, help them change online banking credentials right away. Review recent transfers and new payees with them, and consider reissuing any card they entered or viewed during the session.
The takeaway: the email is just bait to get someone on the phone. The money is lost on the call, through a fake refund that steals bank details or tricks the person into sending money back. A short warning about refunds and remote access keeps the people you serve one step ahead of the scammers when a "friendly" voice offers to fix a charge.